Band needs 8 albums released before they get it right
Why am I supposed to respect these guys again?
Band needs 8 albums released before they get it right
Why am I supposed to respect these guys again?
You're not, if u don't want to
half the songs are the same
early Floyd > post-Meddle sanitized slop
who cares
They couldn't even figure out a proper name for a long time too.
Moronic opinion thread #12489215012
they were named pink floyd on every single album
I like Metallica.
Metallica got it on their 2nd album though.
All those names are peak.
Sigma 6
Spectrum 5
For the early psych rock albums. Same thing The Beatles are praised for and ultimately Jimi Hendrix,Steppenwolf,and every other 60s and 70s band people actually remember save for some prog and soke southern rock ones maybe Glam.
sigma mindset
autism reference
They envisioned brainrot 60 years beforehand. Thats some actual genius.
which one is Leonard?
I was supposed to get today my The Wall LP i ordered, but ill have to wait until tuesday
How do i cope in the meantime?
meddle, Saucerful, and AHM are better than dark side tho
how many of those sold 40 million copies?
Why am I supposed to respect these guys again?
no one cares what you do
i like 'em but it's just simple rock
not exactly Pink Floyd-tier
who cares?
Nothing they made post-Meddle is good, except WYWH.
Hey You alone mogs anything in those albums.
b-but muh Echoes
Literally a jam.
weird take
have you actually heard anything you referenced?
fat old sun, summer 68 and ASB are better than hey you by a mile
pillow of winds too
remember a day + set the controls, + let there be light
Listen better music instead? I don't know
"Weird Take"
Picture of Japanese Porn Actresses or Supermodels or some shit giggling like schoolgirls
"Have you even heard any of"
Sounds like girls made fun of you a lot in either middleschool or high-school. Not sure why you're telling me that but I understand you weren't aware that you did so. Entirely negated by the premise just being your own insecurity.
nothing is more predictable in a music thread than contrarians
this one is truly dumb tho
kek
I'll grant you that the production is super polished (if you go in for that clean slick sound, which some people do), but that's what happens when you throw money and studio engineers at any album. And I'll grant that some of the tracks have pretty good harmonies. Not Lennon/McCartney or Steely Dan tier, but noticeably better than your typical rock band. The problem is that they couldn't write vocal melodies to save themselves, possibly because of Waters's text-centric songwriting outlook, so you these promising song-skeletons end up saddled with a musically listless vocal line that often just repeats the same rhythmically monotonous phrase while hanging around on chord tones. This wouldn't be crippling except that most of the album consists of what are essentially pop songs. I like pop, but not when it's written so poorly. Pink Floyd only redeem themselves on DSOTM when they shut up and play their instruments.
And even then, the Flaming Lips' cover was still a better album.
First day on the board, anon? Don't take things personally.
the Flaming Lips' cover was still a better album
You were doing so well...
If I really wanted to be contrarian why would I mention Jimi Hendrix or The VU? Also popularity be damned are The Beatles NOT contrarian? Like you say this and then half the threads discussing The Beatles are about Blue Jay Way or Reveloution Nine. They had moments of not "boyband" for sure. The Hollies are if anything more conventional and arguably less experimental. I just like what I like though desu. The VU aren't really that obscure either.
No I'm just right lol,basically just told on yourself wildly.
I'll give you that the "all sound the same" guy is retarded though. They had range for sure.
fat old sun
its a beatles/mccartney thing.
summer 68
idk man, so primitive, so old sounding.
look not saying the songs you put there are bad, they were made by very competent musicians, but thats not the pink floyd sound, their music language wasnt as fleshed out and mature there, theyre songs that other bands could have done. but no one else could have made Hey You.
Us (us us us us us us)
And
Them (them them them them them them)
i concede these are good points
masses determine what is good.
Kek that’s good sarcasm
Everything before DTSOM is better than that bloated piece of shit, except maybe Obscured by Clouds. Summer 68' and Fat Old Sun alone BTFO Roger Waters unbearable whining
Dude society LMAO
Dude Syd LMAO
Dude Orwell LMAO
Dude society (and my dad) LMAO
Dude my dad (and my dad) LMAO
nobody thinks pink floyd, "oh yeah the cow album.. mm so good"
they think the nazi walking hammers shit, leave them kids alone, dude breathe and blaze it
roger won bigly, it isnt even up to dispute
nobody thinks "oh yeah the cow album.. mm so good"
I do this and say this
lots of people in this thread disagree
Same!
Band gets filtered by their own album